York Musical Society

Registered Charity Number: 504611

Home Page

Links

Contact Us


About YMS Concerts Members Area

Friends of YMS

 

Concert Review  
 
 

Stanford - 
Stabat Mater & Symphony No. 3 (IRISH)
Saturday 24th March 2007

Review: York Music Society Choir & Orchestra; York Minster

by Martin Dreyer

Congratulations are in order. Apart from his church music, the works of Charles Stanford (1852-1924) are rarely heard in live performance.

Saturday evening's all-Stanford programme may have changed a few minds.

The plaudits must go primarily to Philip Moore, conductor of the York Musical Society forces, for scheduling Stanford's Third Symphony ("Irish") and his Stabat Mater.

The 1887 symphony made international waves - lionised in Hamburg and Berlin , it was on the Concertgebouw Orchestra's opening programme, and Mahler conducted it twice in New York . In England ? After the First World War, it was ignored for 70 years.

On a mere two rehearsals, the orchestra - inexcusably unnamed in the programme - worked wonders.

Moore himself has rarely been so animated on the podium.

The opening Allegro meandered pleasingly, without awakening much expectation. But the strings danced neatly above the Scherzo's martial undercurrents.

Harp and wind arabesques conspired to paint an atmospheric, Celtic landscape in the slow movement, before brass chorales, based on Irish folk-songs, took eventual control of the stirring finale.

The Stabat Mater, premiered in Leeds exactly a century ago, proved equally rousing.

Symphonic in scale and far from sentimental, it found the York Musical Society chorus in excellent voice.

Its two orchestral sections were shot through with drama, while Lorna Anderson floated her soprano effortlessly above the well-balanced solo quartet.

A fiery, not to say thrilling, evening was effectively summarised by the "Inflammatus" stanza near the close. More Stanford, please.


Source: www.thisisyork.co.uk
Reprinted by kind permission of the York & County Press

 

About YMS  |  Concerts  |  Members Area  |  Friends of YMS © 2007 York Musical Society